<

Isn't Life Terrible

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

The Dionnes, Part 3

Sorry for the delay; I need to get some decent video editing software. (The first two video clips are silent, the third has sound.)

Dr. Dafoe quarantined the Dionne Quintuplets "to keep the germs away." That meant keeping people away, too - like the Quints' parents and the rest of their family. The first clip shows the result: Jean Hersholt, who played a version of Dr. Dafoe in the three 20th Century Fox features, presents a puppy to the sisters. They've never seen a puppy before (dogs have germs, except when Hollywood needs a puppy scene), so the sisters are frightened and back away. It was supposed to be a cute scene. You'll see that they stopped the camera, probably had a talk with the girls, then started again. It clearly demonstrates their isolated existence - yet it was used in the feature as you see it here. (36s)



The next clip contains scenes of Quintland, the world's first theme park. It's estimated that three million people made the trip to see the Quints in person. Often, over two miles of stop-and-go traffic "clued everyone in" that they were getting close.

The Dafoe Hospital had an outdoor playground. Surrounding it on three sides was an enclosed, horseshoe-shaped viewing area. Supposedly, the darkness inside the viewing area, coupled with screens of some sort, would make it impossible for the Quints to know that they were being observed. But the quints caught on quickly - they might not have been able to see the tourists, but they certainly could hear them. (1m42s)


What's missing in the story of the Dionne Quintuplets... is a hero. Someone who rides to the rescue. Someone who says "This is wrong and it has to stop."
  • It wasn't Dr. Dafoe, who commandeered the quints, was celebrated by the press as a savior, and made a lot of money.
  • It wasn't Oliva Dionne, whose initial reaction to the birth was to "sell the Quints," in order to make a lot of money.
  • It wasn't Father Daniel Routhier, from whom Oliva Dionne sought guidance and who suggested that, since the children were a miracle from God, 7% of the money should be given to the church.
  • It wasn't Elzire Dionne, who had married at 16 and was the embarrassed mother of 10 at age 25.
  • It wasn't Dr. W.E. Blatz, who headed the team from St. George's School for Child Study at the University of Toronto, who cataloged every move the Quints made but either did not see, or did not want to see, the big picture.
  • It wasn't Mitchell Hepburn, the premier of Ontario, who arranged for the Quints to be taken from their parents legally, via a "guardianship" act that officially gave the government and Dafoe full charge.
Yvonne, Marie, Emilie, Annette and Cecile had to become their own heroes.

They didn't all make it through... but as this 'behind the scenes' production video for the TV movie "Million Dollar Babies" shows, Yvonne, Cecile, and Annette Dionne lived to tell the tale. (8m21s)



Quints Digitization Project
Quintland Site
Second Birthday Party (Audio)
Picture Album

Labels:

7 Comments:

  • Too bad Homer Simpson wasn't around to help.

    By Blogger Jack Ruttan, At January 9, 2008 at 12:35 PM  

  • I just finished readind Paul De Kruif´s book "Why Keep them Alive? and the final chapter dedicated to the Dionnes got me wondering about finding info on them and that´s how I arrived here! The story of how those quintuplets mocked death is really inspiring.

    By Blogger Carlos, At May 12, 2008 at 11:05 PM  

  • Since seeing the film as a child I have been interested in the Dionne's. This is a fantastic page to come across. Thank you.

    19, UK.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At November 25, 2008 at 7:03 PM  

  • Gosh, those poor girls...makes me so sad to know they were made into a freak show, and exploited like that.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At January 29, 2009 at 12:42 PM  

  • Dear Don,
    For the life of me now I can't remember how I came across your blogs 5 clicks ago, but I wanted to say "Thank You" for putting together this brief synopsis of the Dionne sisters' early lives. As you may have gathered from my last name I am distantly related to them. My father (b 1935) was 4 or 5th cousins, unfortunately, by the time I came around in the late 60's the family had fallen into a "don't ask, don't tell" situation because most were so embarassed about the whole affair. I'm sorry I, nor my father, never got to meet any of the sisters. All I could have said to them was "Thank you", thank you for unwillingly giving the world a lift out of the Great Depression, and "I'm so sorry", I'm so very, very sorry they (all of them, the government, the press, the public, etc) treated you that way.
    Your birth may have been deemed a miracle, but that you came through it all with your heads held high is perhaps even more miraculous.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At February 14, 2009 at 8:07 PM  

  • Is the same thing going to happen to the Suleman Octuplets?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At February 28, 2009 at 9:42 PM  

  • This story makes me want to cry:( Im so angry and hurt about what these beautiful little girls had to go through. I'm so sorry.

    By Anonymous Miriam Galarza, At June 26, 2009 at 2:04 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



<< Home